A Family Investment Debate - Filter Coffee and Fibonacci

Fundamental vs Technical Analysis  : A Tale of Two Investment Styles

“Markets are running wild again,” muttered Srini as he sipped his evening filter coffee.

Srini, a Chartered Accountant, had spent decades advising clients and dissecting balance sheets. Sitting across from him was his brother, Vaidy, a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) who believed in steady, long-term investing based on business fundamentals.

“Earnings season has begun,” Vaidy nodded, scrolling through results on his tablet. “Let’s see who walks the talk.”

Just then, Ramesh their jijaji walked in, holding his phone up triumphantly. “You guys still stuck with your balance sheets and quarterly reports? Look at the charts! The price action tells the real story.”

Ramesh was the family’s go-to guy for technical analysis - a trained expert who swore by candlestick patterns, moving averages, and trendlines.

Behind him followed Aditya - Ramesh’s son and Srini & Vaidy’s nephew also a CA, working in merchant banking. He was full of energy and fascination for markets. “Mama, I’ve been backtesting some momentum strategies. Technicals are all about timing,” he grinned.

Two Worlds, One Market

Srini raised an eyebrow. “Timing? You mean picking stocks based on squiggly lines?”

“Not squiggly lines” Ramesh laughed. “Support, resistance, RSI, moving averages - these aren’t guesses. They’re signals. They help you ride the waves.”

Vaidy leaned in, smiling. “But where’s the value? We look at the business - its earnings, debt, promoter quality, and growth story. That’s what builds real wealth.”

Srini added, “Would you buy a house based on its paint job or its foundation? A stock is no different. We prefer to know what we’re buying.”

“But even the best houses don’t sell if the market’s cold,” Aditya replied. “Look at Tata Motors - while fundamentals were still recovering, the chart showed breakouts with strong volumes. If you waited for earnings, you'd have missed the rally.”

Fundamentals vs Technicals - The Core Differences

Fundamental Analysis - Focuses on what a company is worth based on earnings, assets, and economic environment. It’s about long-term investing and understanding business quality.

Technical Analysis - Focuses on how the stock price behaves. Uses price charts, trends, and trading volumes to make short- to medium-term predictions.

Srini smiled. “See, Aditya, as a CA, you know how important it is to analyze a company’s cash flows and ROCE. That gives confidence to stay invested even during volatility.”

“And as a planner,” Vaidy added, “I’ve seen how quality businesses reward patience. That’s what I tell my clients.”

Ramesh leaned back. “Agreed. But sometimes even great companies underperform for years. That’s where technicals help. It’s like driving with both a road map and a weather forecast.”

The Middle Path

Aditya paused. “Maybe that’s the real answer. It’s not about which method is better. Why not use both?”

“Start with fundamentals to choose the right stock, then use technicals to time the entry and exit,” he suggested.

Srini turned to Vaidy, who gave a quiet nod. “The new generation is bringing a fresh perspective - we’ve got to give them credit.”

“Fusion analysis!” Ramesh declared. “We’ll call it that.”

Laughter filled the room as the debate mellowed into mutual respect for different strategies - all part of the same goal: smarter investing.

To sum up, Fundamental analysis tells you what to buy, while technical analysis helps decide when to buy (or sell). In today’s dynamic markets, combining both gives investors an edge - balancing deep insight with sharp timing.

The content made available in this article is for general informational purposes only. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the content, it should not be considered as a substitute for professional consultation. 

About the Author